The Dog Food Dilemma: Why a Century of Marketing Is Obsolete in the AI Age

AI & SocietyAI Strategy
Written By Paul F. Accornero

Frequently Asked Questions (The Executive Summary)

What is the "Dog Food Dilemma"?

It's a classic marketing problem that highlights the difference between the end-user of a product (the consumer) and the person who buys it (the shopper). For a century, marketing has focused on persuading the human shopper, who may be influenced by factors other than the product's core quality.

What is the "Shopper Schism” (Great Decoupling)?

The

Shopper Schism (or Great Decoupling) is the irreversible split between the human consumer and the transactional shopper, driven by AI. Humans are beginning to delegate the task of shopping to non-human AI agents, or

Algorithmic Shoppers, which act purely on logic and data on behalf of the consumer.

There’s a legendary story in the marketing world, often attributed to the Alpo dog food brand. After a massive, expensive, and award-winning advertising campaign, the company’s sales remained stubbornly flat. In a tense executive meeting, the chairman supposedly silenced the room with a simple, brutal truth: "The dogs have to eat the dog food."

This wasn't just a clever line. It was a perfect articulation of the fundamental tension at the heart of all commerce, a problem that has defined a century of marketing strategy: the person who uses the product (the consumer) is not always the same person who buys it (the shopper). The dog is the consumer with a need; the owner is the shopper with a wallet. For a hundred years, the entire discipline of marketing has been a masterful exercise in solving this dilemma by persuading the human shopper.

The foundational premise on which the entire discipline is based is now obsolete. The ground has shifted beneath our feet, and the solution we perfected no longer works.

We are living through the first moments of the

Shopper Schism (Great Decoupling)—the irreversible schism between the human consumer and the transactional shopper. For generations, these two roles were fused in a single, persuadable person. Now, AI is splitting them apart. The role of the shopper—once a human you could influence with a great story, a beautiful package, or a clever ad—is being delegated to a new, non-human economic actor: the

Algorithmic Shopper.

This is not an evolution; it’s a replacement. The Algorithmic Shopper is a dispassionate AI agent, programmed to act in its user's best interest with perfect memory and flawless, logical reasoning. It is immune to clever packaging and unmoved by aspirational advertising. It cannot be influenced, only convinced by verifiable data.

Think back to the Dog Food Dilemma. The dog (the consumer) always wanted the most nutritious, best-tasting food. The owner (the shopper), however, could be influenced by a compelling commercial, a picture of a happy dog on the bag, or a price promotion. Marketing’s job was to bridge that gap—to convince the owner that what they wanted to buy was also what the dog needed.

The Algorithmic Shopper changes the game completely. It acts as a perfect, incorruptible agent for the consumer. It will not be swayed by the branding on the bag; it will parse the ingredient list. It won't be moved by the commercial; it will analyze the nutritional data and cross-reference it with veterinarian reviews and reports on long-term health outcomes. The new shopper is, for the first time in history, capable of making a purely rational decision on behalf of the consumer.

The strategic implications are seismic. Your marketing team, your sales force, your entire commercial strategy—all are built to persuade a human shopper that is rapidly disappearing. You've spent decades and billions of dollars becoming experts at talking to the owner, but now you have to learn how to talk to the dog—or more precisely, to its ruthlessly logical AI agent.

The new mandate is clear. Stop focusing on persuading the shopper and start obsessing over building a product whose value can be proven, quantified, and audited by a machine. Your beautiful brand story is becoming a null data point. Your verifiable supply chain, your product's measurable performance, your quantifiable impact—that is your new marketing.

The dogs—and their algorithmic agents—are about to eat the dog food they truly want. The only question is whether you’re the one making it.

Paul F. Accornero

Paul F. Accornero is a C-suite leader, global strategist, and the author of the forthcoming book, The Algorithmic Shopper. He currently serves as the Global Chief Commercial Officer for one of the world's market-leading consumer goods companies, where he is a key architect of its global commercial strategy. In this role, he directs a multi-billion-euro business with a P&L spanning over 120 countries and is responsible for the performance of thousands of employees worldwide.

Paul stands at the intersection of classic brand building and the next frontier of commerce. His career has been defined by leading profound organizational and digital transformations for some of the world's most iconic consumer brands. For over a decade at the L'Oréal Group, he was instrumental in shaping commercial policy and strategy across the Asia Pacific region, including serving as Chief Commercial Officer for the Consumer Products Division in P.R. China. Since 2008, he has been a driving force behind the globalization of his current company, spearheading the omnichannel strategies that have successfully navigated the disruption of the digital age. His leadership has a proven track record of delivering exceptional results, including driving revenue growth exceeding.

His unique perspective is not merely academic; it has been forged through decades of hands-on operational experience and senior leadership roles on multiple continents. He has served as CEO, President, or Managing Director for major subsidiaries in the USA, Japan, and Singapore, giving him an unparalleled, ground-level view of the global commercial landscape he deconstructs in his work.

A rigorous strategic framework complements this extensive real-world experience. A graduate of the University of Queensland, Paul completed his postgraduate business studies at Harvard Business School, where he studied disruptive strategy under the world’s foremost thought leaders, including the late Clayton Christensen. This blend of C-suite practice and elite academic insight makes him uniquely positioned to write the definitive playbook for the age of AI-driven commerce.

As an active and respected industry leader, Paul is a Fellow of both the Institute of Directors (FIoD) and the Chartered Institute of Marketing (FCIM) in the UK. He is also a Liveryman of the World Traders Livery Company and a Freeman of the City of London, affiliations that connect him to a deep network of influential business leaders.

The Algorithmic Shopper is more than a book; it is the culmination of a career spent leading on the front lines of commercial evolution.

https://theaipraxis.ai
Next

The Automaton Economy (Part 5): The Path to a World After Work